A blog about nothing in particular. A place to share ideas in a civil manner.
Monday, January 21, 2013
Long Silver, Short Gold Play Continues To Work Well
Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More...)
A few key pieces of information on precious metals caught my attention this week, which continues to support my thesis that 2013 will be a year where gold (GLD) will continue to underperform against silver (SLV). I wrote an article about this topic about a month ago. Let's examine how gold and silver have performed in the last month.
As the chart shows, both are up, but silver is outperforming gold by a factor of 3. Let's examine the key news that came out this week to see if this trend has legs.
First, the news on silver.
There seems to be a shortage of silver right now. This is not surprising. As industrial demand grows with the economic recovery in China, silver, a key industrial commodity, is in high demand. As reported by Seeking Alpha commentator Dave Kranzler:
I have a couple different business colleagues who have spoken with bullion smelters who say the market is in short supply right now. Furthermore, Swiss money manager Egon Von Greyerz statedyesterday that "we are now seeing very lengthy delays in getting physical silver."
How have investors reacted to the anticipated increase in silver demand, and hence higher prices? As reported by ETFtrends.com:
The iShares Silver Trust has gathered inflows of more than $600 million so far this week, which represents approximately 6% of the assets under management in the fund, to lead all ETFs.
This has led to a sharp rally in silver, as is clear from the chart above. I continue to be bullish on economic growth, especially from China. As reported by Seeking Alpha:
Chinese Q4 GDP rises 7.9% Y/Y vs. 7.8% consensus, 7.4% prior. December industrial production +10.3% Y/Y vs. 10.2% consensus. December retail sales +15.2% Y/Y vs. 15.1% consensus.
China is the engine that has been driving world industrial growth. If the outlook is positive for China, I believe that it is positive for silver as well. So, I continue to be bullish on silver.
Next, the news on gold.
Gold demand in aggregate continues to be weak. A reported by
Most key gauges of risk assets, like the S&P 500 or other major global stock indexes, are near decade highs. Thanks to unprecedented stimulus actions from the US, EU, and Japan, they have held on within 10% of these highs (about 1550 on the S&P 500 for example) for most of 2012 despite mostly dismal fundamentals.
As we argued in our 4 part overview of 2013 forecasts, one's outlook for 2013 depends on whether you believe markets can continue being propped up artificially by assorted stimulus programs comprised mostly of deficit spending with printed money. As noted in section 6 below, it's not clear. In the above 4 part series we argued that one should not fight a central bank action of this magnitude. That means you don't open any long term shorts until you've evidence of a technical breakdown.
But does it still pay to open new long positions? The short answer is probably not, as we'll discuss in the conclusions section below.
Here's our latest collection of evidence that markets are seriously overbought, and some ideas on what to do to protect yourself and profit.
1. Continued Evidence of Slowing Global Growth
The world bank cut global growth forecasts last week. That shouldn't surprise anyone given that Japan Europe, and the UK are all in recession. China is slowing, and we can expect similar slowing from the other export oriented nations, given that their customers have less to spend. Friday's US UoM consumer sentiment report confirms that the world's biggest group of consumers isn't optimistic.
2. Austerity, Slowing Growth Coming To US Too
No matter what the final deal (or series of temporary deals) on the coming fiscal cliffs and debt ceiling fights, even the most bullish scenario brings at least some kind of tax increases and spending cuts, such as those imposed in the latest fiscal cliff deal, which is expected to cut 1%-1.5% from a US annual GDP that was running just over 2% (versus the average 3.6 % US GDP from 1950-99 and Fed's original 4.5% forecast for 2012).
Future deals are likely to yield similar results - deals that produce some kind of "lesser of evils" scenario in which debt growth slows (but continues to rise) while weak growth gets weaker from the minimal austerity steps taken.
3. So Earnings To Drop Too
Q3 2012 earnings fell short, and thus far Q4 looks no better. These results make sense given the above.
4. Time Is Not On Our Side: Market Cycle Perspective
From a market cycle perspective, major stock indexes remain near decade highs that most likely mean the end of a bull cycle within a longer term secular bear market. See here for details.
5. A Series of Unfortunate Events: Other Technical And Sentiment Readings
The following set of conditions is one way to capture the basic "overvalued, overbought, overbullish, rising-yields" syndrome:
1) S&P 500 more than 8% above its 52 week (exponential) average 2) S&P 500 more than 50% above its 4-year low 3) Shiller P/E greater than 18 4) 10-year Treasury yield higher than 6 months earlier 5) Advisory bullishness > 47%, with bearishness < 27% (Investor's Intelligence)
6. History: Current Conditions Suggest 10% - 20% Drop
History suggests current conditions mean the next move is down, at least 10%, possibly in excess of 20%.
In a note to clients, Societe Generale's bearish strategist Albert Edwardsnoted that "U.S. S&P rally from low looks spookily similar to 2007," saying that the S&P 500 is exactly 807 points above its March 2009 low of 666. From its 2002 low to its 2007 high, the S&P 500 moved exactly 807 points.
While he concedes that the S&P could yet reach around 1500 (it closed last week at 1485), he sees the market due for a pullback in excess of 20% to around 1200. Admittedly that's not much beyond a normal technical pullback, but it's one you'd rather avoid if possible. Key points include:
The Bullish Evidence Isn't So Bullish
Housing has improved, but only a bit compared to its peak just over 6 years ago. It's still way below that level (me: or even averages of the past decade).
Stocks overall flat for over a decade: The 120 % rally since 2009 only brings leading indexes back to their 1999 level, and we're still a bit below the 2000 and 2007 highs. The secular bear remains intact.
As we noted above, US and global growth is stagnant, and US growth is likely to slow given even relatively minimal new efforts to make slow deficit growth.
Since the start of QE3, or QE-infinity there's been no meaningful improvement in stock prices, employment, or wages.
He adds (along with most other analysts) that central bank intervention is unsustainable and (as suggested above) both US and global economies are expected to be flat to lower for the year ahead, and that he sees no compelling fundamental reasons that risk assets should make another sustained break higher.
From Citibank's Peter Lee
Per Lee, the picture is potentially bleaker, who see's the S&P 500 (and by extension other risk assets making a similar drop) reverting back down to its long term uptrend line, meaning it's due for a roughly 50% drop in the coming years to around 750 - 850 per his long term studies dating back to the 1800s. See here for the full article and some disturbing charts.
7. EU Risk Complacency
As we wrote last week here, the widespread notion that EU crisis risk is over, aided and abetted by EU officials, is arguably 2012's biggest lie and 2013's biggest risk. In addition to what we've said earlier about how nothing of note has improved in the EU (except its ability to provide some short term liquidity) and that instead there is every reason to believe things are fundamentally worse, we already have news this past week that yet another warning, this time via the IMF, of more haircuts for Greek bondholders.
On the (Relatively) Bullish Side
There are more optimistic views from those who deserve to be taken very seriously.
Goldman's Hatzius More Optimistic
Regarding the US, Goldman Sach's to economist Jan Hatzius sees 9 bullish reasons to believe US markets don't become unglued in the first half of 2013, and then see modest increase in growth in the second half.
Note however, that his positive outlook for the second half depends on two positive outcomes, neither of which is assured.
The recent and future fiscal cliff and debt ceiling deals don't cause real income growth to go negative on a year-over-year basis. Whenever that has happened there has been a recession. He acknowledges it could happen but believes the likelihood is that it doesn't. See here for the full article.
The current calm about the EU crisis continues. He believes (me too) that the EU crisis has been the prime market driver for the US since mid 2011. See here for details and supporting chart.
BofA/ML's Bartels: 10-15% Correction A Last, Best Buying Opportunity
Based on her view of past patterns and trading ranges, BofA/ML's technical analyst Mary Ann Bartels, sees a possible 10-15% correction in 2013 (well within the range of a normal technical pullback)as a multi-year low and start of the next leg higher of about 500 points or more on the S&P 500.
Davos Schwab Says Iran, Syria ‘Black Swans’ as Euro Crisis Fades
Klaus Schwab, founder of the World Economic Forum, sees political “black swan” events threatening global security even as economic risks subside, with confidence returning to the euro area.
“The world is still full of risks and we do not have only to address the economic risks, I think it is very important that we become more resilient in terms of the political risks,” Schwab, 78, said in an Bloomberg Television interview in Davos yesterday. “There are many black swans round,” he said, referring to the Japan-China dispute in the East China Sea, the Syrian civil war and the nuclear inspections in Iran.
Black-swan events, named after the belief that all swans were white until the discovery of black ones in Australia in 1697, describe extreme outcomes such as the 2008 financial crisis that were previously considered very unlikely to happen. A World Economic Forum survey presented earlier this month found that income disparities and government budget deficits present the most likely risks to the global economy in the next decade.
Schwab, who founded the annual meeting of political and business leaders in 1971, said that he expects Northern Africa, Syria and the war in Mali to be “hot issues” at the Forum, which starts tomorrow, while the euro-region crisis “will not play such a big role as it did the last year.”
“I think we have certain signs that at least we have stabilized the situation,” Schwab said, adding that a breakup of the common currency was “definitely” off the table. “There might again be a crisis mode, but there will not be a breakup, because we have seen in Europe sufficient political will to make sure that Europe remains as a unity.”